Dissecting (Dis)Content pt 2: The 8 Layers of Market Research


For years we've heard the phrases "Provide value" and "Be engaging" but these are so vague and lack definition.

As someone who has studied storytelling from age 10 - first as a career actor, then as a marketer - I believe there are multiple principles that can be taken from film theory and behavioral psych and ancient philosophy that can help us create stuff that can be valuable and resonate at a deeper level.

But to do that, we first need to know what that value is, why the person on the other side of the screen will find it valuable, and where we're going to meet them so we can deliver the right value at the right time.

Of course, the only way to do that is through market research.

In this email:

  • The shocking lack of market research in the content marketing space
  • 3 hypothesis as to why this is happening
  • The 8 Layer Market Research Process to create more resonate content, build distribution, and get more buy-in

Let's go.

From The State of (Dis)Content Report:

This was the most shocking stat when it came to the report and one I keep coming back to as I talk about it.

41.3% of content marketing professionals report not doing their audience research "nearly enough".

I can not begin to stress how much of a negative impact across all other vectors of the survey, such as:

  • Career and creative satisfaction
  • Confidence in voice and tone
  • Relationship with the work
  • Compensation fulfillment
  • Leadership buy-in

Now, since the report's been live, there's been a solid case made there's the chicken and egg scenario where the lack of leadership (or client) buy-in prohibits content marketers from carrying out meaningful research.

There's also an argument to made that there's such a strong focus on production, production, production that doing audience research is just another thing to add on.

I really hate this argument, because if the content being produced isn't getting shared, discussed, generating leads, or making sales, it's ineffective and you're just "playing content" and burning cash.

There's some merit to both of these arguments, but personally, I think there's one major reason why this happens:

There isn't proper training.

Nobody I've ever met said "I want to be a content marketer when I grow up" as a kid.

Most I've known were writers, journalists, or something else when they got in the field. Like I said earlier, I was an actor.

Coming from humanities backgrounds, that means most of us don't have a formal research background that bridges the gap from creative work to business results.

Couple that with the fact that "Audience research" is such an amorphous phrase that means many things to many people.

If the qualitative feedback from the survey tells me anything, a good deal of people, even those who say they're doing it, don't have a real defined process for themselves.

It's no wonder so many content marketers have a hard time carrying it out or communicating what it is they're even trying to do so they can take the time to do it.

That's why "The 8 Layer Market Research Process" exists

I've developed this process over the past 10 years and it's one that's been at the foundation of the content strategies I've built for companies like Shopify Plus and QuickBooks.

The 8 Layer Market Research Process is designed to help you:

  1. Build connections within your (or your client's) company and stop being siloed.
  2. Create a distribution network so your content doesn't get launched into the ether.
  3. Systematically dismantle competitor messaging to create differentiated content.
  4. Understand the "click-triggers" that get a market to share, discuss, and buy-in.
  5. Hedge your bets against failures on content launches.

That's just a handful of the main benefits of this process.

What is the real purpose of research?

Before doing any research, you need to know the ultimate goal:

What does your audience want?
What does your audience need?

Wants are the conscious desire they have that is specific to them and will help them achieve their ultimate goal.

Needs on the other hand are often unknown or ignored, universal to everyone, and helps them develop as a person.

My favorite example of this is a topic many people might be familiar with:

"How to build a landing page."

On the surface, someone looking for a topic like this might want to know the basics.

  • Hero image
  • Headline
  • Body copy
  • CTA
  • Micro-copy

What they need to know however depends on what you sell.

For example, if you sold A/B testing software, what they would really need to know is:

  1. Nobody in the company is going to agree on anything
  2. Each of these components can be tested
  3. The underlying message is the more important than any test

By weaving those elements throughout, your content - written, audio, or otherwise - goes from providing information to communicating ideas.

What those idea are, who you're communicating them to, and where you're communicating them, well...

That's how the layers and how they are used

Ok, I've teased you enough, these are The 8 Layers of Market Research

1. You

What are your core brand narratives?

What's your company's take on your category, your product, your customers, and the culture they're supposed to live in?

Many content folks I've met don't think this is up to them because the "brand" team takes care of it. Maybe. But if the content team lives in a silo, wouldn't it be nice to break down barriers and get to hear it from your colleagues?

2. Your customers

What do they value? What do they fear? What are their strategies for success?

What is the common spark that connects them to each other?

What is the shared interest and passion?

This is the shared DNA that connects your customers

3. Your direct competitors

Take all of the things they do the same (big logos, shared language, etc.) and cancel them out.

Prospects do.

Once those are gone, what's the substance behind what they're saying?

4. Your search competitors

Not everyone who shows up in the same SERPs are your direct competitors. In fact, they may be potential partners. Take advantage of that.

5. Industry adjacent

Think apps, agencies, or conferences that target the same customer.

Here's another opportunity to find allies and opportunities to spread your message.

6. News

You want your references to be timely right?

Might also be good to know if you ever wade into digital PR territory.

7. Influencers

Who's driving the conversation? Potential partnership opportunity? Could be.

8. Pulse

How do you keep track of all this in real time?

Take 30 minutes in the morning so you can stay on top of what's happening in the industry and either feed it to the company, into your content, or both.

This is the foundation of Content Theory

The idea behind The 8 Layer process is that we create a total awareness of the market so we can continuously identify gaps so we can create the things nobody else can.

After all, you can't create a signal if you don't understand the noise.

There's more to it, but those are the basics.

If you're interested in learning more about The 8 Layer Market Research Framework and how we build upon it to build distinct and differentiated content programs, you should join me for my one week summit running from November 11th - 15th.

Each day is packed full of the knowledge I've gained over a 19+ year career and from my experiences at building content programs for companies like Shopify Plus, QuickBooks, and several other mid-market companies.

There are only 15 spots left.

If you'd like to learn more, reply to this email and we'll get into the details.

See you tomorrow.

Tommy Walker | The Content Studio

Talk to me about Content Theory

P.S... This is just one of the many strategies and tactics I teach in my course, Content Theory.

In it we go in depth on…

  • The 3 types of audience channels to tailor your content and get them to advocate for your brand.
  • The Content Code to help you scale a research-backed standard of quality for your team and upper management.
  • 10+ tactics to dissect content that your audience already enjoys consuming and use that as a springboard to build content programs that stand the test of time and technology.

If you’re ready to go from zero creative ideas to becoming known as a creative content partner in your organization, click on this link to enroll for the next cohort.

The Studio Insider

Tommy Walker is the founder of The Content Studio, a content marketing consultancy for Fortune 1,000 companies and fast growing B2B startups. Prior to founding The Content Studio, Tommy was the Global Editor-in-Chief at QuickBooks, and the first marketing hire at Shopify Plus. Currently, he hosts "The Cutting Room" where he interviews industry-leading marketers about their content marketing philosophy, process, and pre-game before they edit an article live. Guests have been from companies like Asana, Calendly, Docusign, Vimeo and more.

Read more from The Studio Insider

Now that The State of (Dis)Content Report is finally out, I’d like to talk about a few of the specific data points and see if we can pick them apart and push past some of these challenges we've been having. Over the next few days, I’d like to read between the lines and point out what I think are the root issues of content marketing, and provide suggestions on how to overcome them. I'm calling the series: Dissecting (Dis)Content You may agree with my assessments (I hope you do), you may not...

Remember the first time you got hooked on a band or musician that was way outside what you normally listen to? Or when that friend said, “No, you HAVE to watch this movie” and you were blown away, even though it never would have crossed your radar?That’s the exact reason I hate the idea that so many people believe “Quality” is subjective. There’s “content” out there that, even if it doesn’t suit your preferences, is objectively good.“Alien” and “Forrest Gump” are often considered objectively...

Welcome new readers, and hello old friends. Now that The State of (Dis)Content Report is finally out, I’m picking The Studio Insider back up so we can talk about the specific data points and see what we can do next to continue pushing our industry forward. Over the next few weeks, I’m going to read between the lines and point out what I think are the root issues of content marketing, and provide suggestions on how to overcome them. I'm calling the series: The 5 Content Marketing Challenges of...